Cashback vs Rewards Points Calculator

Compare a flat cashback card with a points card by annual spend, point value and annual fee.

About this tool

Cashback = spend x rate. Points value = spend x points per dollar x cents per point, minus the annual fee. Point values depend on how you redeem.

Frequently asked questions

Is cashback or points better?

It depends on how you redeem points. Points beat flat cashback only if their value per point and earn rate outweigh the annual fee.

What is a typical value per point?

Many programs are worth around 1 to 2 cents per point, depending on how you redeem, such as travel versus statement credit.

Should I count the annual fee?

Yes. Subtract it from the points value before comparing against a no-fee cashback card.